Great Men: What Defines Them?

“I should say sincerity, a deep, great, genuine sincerity, is the first characteristic of all men in any way heroic.”

Thomas Carlyle

And in our story from future past….

A Music Video

The Great Duke – Copyright 2026 by J.R. Nyquist

Carlye’s Great Man Theory

Thomas Carlyle wrote, “The History of the world is the Biography of great men.” In a nutshell, this is the “Great Man Theory” of history. The subject of greatness involves us in puzzles and moral complexities. Yet Carlyle is useful because he is brimming with insights.

As the Story of Black Eugene gives us a villain to contemplate, shouldn’t we have a hero to set on the opposite side? What is heroic? Why are we presently overrun with celebrities who are mistaken for heroes? What makes a great man? Does a great man have to read books? Somone put these questions to me last week. In answer to him, I composed and produced the music video above. Yet my idea of heroic behavior is hardly the end-all and be-all.

While attempting to answer a reader’s query about Great Men, I referred to Carlyle. The reader seemed to react negatively to the fact that in Carlyle’s book on heroism he listed Mahomet as a Great Man. How could this be? I replied that Carlyle’s judgments are sometimes controversial. Yet Carlyle had a definite scheme in mind when he chose Mohamet as a hero. According to Carlyle, heroes are people who are not the creation of their environment; rather, they are the creators and shapers of their environment. In this context, Carlyle enumerated six heroic guises: divinity, prophet, poet, priest, man of letters, and king. Keeping in mind that heroes are makers of the world rather than made by the world, Carlyle chose the following representatives of greatness: Odin, Mahomet, Shakespeare, Luther, Johnson, and Napoleon.

The qualification of greatness being a man who shapes the world as opposed to being shaped by helps the clarify a few things. However, it also creates a problem for us. If greatness belongs to those who shape the world, then Lenin, Stalin, Mao and Hitler would be Great Men. However, Carlyle offers us some qualifiers. He says that the Great Man is essentially sincere. At one point Carlyle wrote, “I wish you to take this as my primary definition of a Great Man.”

The other qualification of a Great Man set down by Carlyle was something many people would find difficult. He said that a Great Man sees into the nature of things. He has the gift of discernment. This is most clearly seen in prophets, and this is something Carlyle attempts to demonstrate in the biography of Mahomet, whether we ultimately agree with him or not.

Last but not least, Carlyle thought that a Great Man is someone who meets some essential need of his time. Furthermore, he is capable of destructive and creative acts. Such acts, on his part, are not arbitrary or drawn from egotism. It is in these qualities that primitive man saw Great Men as divinities. And it is no accident that some antiquarians came to believe that the original gods of Egypt, Mesopotamia and Greece were merely Great Men.

Carlyle seems to say that Great Men are only raised up when Providence is in need of them. Perhaps the normal course is for Great Men to get ground under by inferior men, since inferior men are unable to stand greatness at close quarters (insofar as greatness puts them to shame). Here we see the character of Black Eugene in high relief. Carlyle takes this as a realistic point of departure. Since heroes, possessing greatness within themselves, are subject to persecution for their good qualities, they are only called forth if (1) the right circumstances arise and (2) God is willing.

In terms of literary men, Carlyle made an unusual suggestion,

“Literature, so far as it is Literature, is an ‘apocalypse of Nature,’ a revealing of the ‘open secret.’ It may well be named, in Fichte’s style, a ‘continuous revelation’ of the Godlike in the Terrestrial and Common. The Godlike does ever, in very truth, endure there; is brought out, now in this dialect, now in that, with various degrees of clearness: all true gifted Singers and Speakers are, consciously or unconsciously, doing so.”

In conclusion it is worth adding that Carlyle thought Great Men could lose their greatness and fail. This is how he interpreted Napoleon’s career. In this and other points we find that the subject of Great Men is far from exhausted, being exhaustible.


One response to “Great Men: What Defines Them?”

  1. italiano89 Avatar
    italiano89

    Hello Jeff,

    I have catching up to do of the Spotify Dynamic Independent Podcasts & Lees Youtube Podcasts.

    I was listening to, catching up on the Past Month to Month & a Half of Spotify, when you mentioned about Trump for a few Podcasts. On that he has not done well for the Country at all. You even mentioned a few times, that you lost Readers. I want to say thank you for doing that, speaking the Truth. I voted for him in 2016, but stopped supporting him a 100% a Month into his First Term, because he listened to his Daughter Ivanka & attacked some Country. After that, I was a little iffy about him. A year into his First Term, I became extremely disappointed in him. After that until 2020, gave up on him. When 2020 came, I have been suspicious of him, I feel he betrayed the Country that Year, giving the Governors the Money. As well as that Vaccine. Ever since then, I cant stomach him, I feel he is a NY Democrat, & a Fraud. He still says he is the Father of the Vaccines. So again, thank you for your honesty, and courage.I believe the Man really damaged this Country.

    I listened to you Months ago on Tommys Podcast, TPC. Im basically his age & I worry a lot on whats going to happen.

    A couple of questions please:

    The Fourth Turning Book, which I believe they took that idea from someone else. Its about Cycles of History. Now, is there any hope for Europe to keep its Heritage? I’m not racist or against anyone. I do see, mainly Whites in Europe & the US, having low birth rates, along with the illegal immigration, & legal immigration, gay agenda, LGBTQ, Woke, also mixed reltionships/marriages. The way I see it, it looks like Whites are going to become almost Exctinct. Again, I’m not against anyone & I’m not racist either. Do you know where the Mixed Reltionships/Marriages are coming from? You have idiots, saying its Zionists. If Trump really cared, he would do what Ann Coulter suggested, which was to Reverse the Immigration Act of 1965, that LBJ the Socialist helped pass.

    Ron Desantis, recently said that its better for a Republican to run in 2032, because if they win in 2028, they wont be able to pass anything before 2032, because the Democrats will still be in control. Do you think he is right? I see Ron Desantis as the only choice we have for President. The idea of JD Vance or some other RHINO makes me sick. Marco Rubio, I don’t think would do enough. I think Desantis is our only hope.

    Also when I listened to the Past Month or so on the Dynamic Podcast, you mentioned Russia wants to do a White National Capital with Europe & Others under its Control. I forgot what it was exactly called, can you please say what that is all about?

    What is your take on the prophecies of garabandal? I did ask one day on Dynamic Live on Lees Youtube, Johnny wanted me to ask when you are on live, but I work when you are on live.

    There is a really good Book not sure if you ever heard of it called: Theodore Roosevelt, the Progressive Party, and the Transformation of American Democracy by Sidney M Milkis. It showed that 100 years ago, that the Progressives(Socialists), used State Rights, to Transform America . Can our Side implement Freedom like Nullification(No Succession as we need a Fed Gov), to help Save America?

    I know that in the Podcasts, you guys mentioned that Russia has a lot of bots & trolls, all fake, that pump all of the disinformation that People believe.

    Do you know about Charlotte Iserbyt?

    She was Anti Communist, but got fired by Reagan, because she wrote him a letter basically, warning him of the Communists, & to get rid of the Dept of Ed. She has on her Website https://deliberatedumbingdown.com/ about this, a Pamphlet on Reagan exposing him when he was Governor of CA, Reagan a Traitor, signing us onto with the Soviets in Education Agreements, & other things about the Communist Infultrated into America. Please look into her. Our Education System, has been infultrated since the mid 1800s, due to the Local & State Governments basically Socializing Education, from the Prussian System.

    There was another Person, who really went into the History, called John Taylor Gatto as well.

    I’am trying to get my hands on as many things as possible that has you in interviews.

    Im sure you have been told this before, you are extremely brilliant.

    Everytime, you mention a book I write it down & put it in my huge get book list.

    I listened to Today, called from 2 Years ago:Entrevista com Jeffrey Nyquist. That was beyond amazing, I loved especially at the end of these Philosophers you mentioned.

    My apologies for the 10000 Questions. I figure I post this on here, because I work when you are live. I could also email you instead if you want. You have really opened up my eyes, since about 6 Months ago, I have read the Books you mention, such as the Defector books, & wow! Again, you are extremely intelligant, & want to become informed as much as you are, & hopefully I can educate others, I do share your website along with interviews with others. I have one of your books, I have your other books on my big list. Thanks! -Mike
    (Jerzeys2finest89 on Youtube)

Leave your thoughts

Discover more from J.R. Nyquist Blog

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading